ICONOS FINALES-TRAZADOS

 

AGENCY AGREEMENT: IN GOOWILL INDEMNITY LOST IF THE AGREEMENT IS NOT RENEWED?

AGENCY AGREEMENT: IN GOOWILL INDEMNITY LOST IF THE AGREEMENT IS NOT RENEWED?

The duration of the agreement and the manner in which the relationship ends can be decisive in preserving this right.

An agent's decision not to enter into a new agreement upon expiry of the previous one may allow the agent to retain the right to goodwill indemnity. The key lies in distinguishing between the expiry of an agreed contractual term and the termination of an agreement of indefinite duration by notice.

GOODWILL INDEMNITY MAY BE PAYABLE UNDER BOTH TYPES OS AGREEMENT 

Law 12/1992 of 27 May on Agency Agreements (LCA) incorporated Directive 86/653/EEC into Spanish law. Its strongly protective approach towards commercial agents is reflected in the regulation of goodwill indemnity, which applies to both fixed-term and indefinite-term agreements.

In both cases, entitlement to indemnity requires the conditions set out in Article 28 of the LCA to be met:

  • The introduction of new customers or a substantial increase in business with existing customers.
  • The agent's previous activities must be capable of continuing to provide substantial benefits to the principal.
  • Payment of the indemnity must be equitable in light of the circumstances of the case.

Therefore, neither a fixed nor an indefinite duration automatically excludes entitlement to indemnity. However, the distinction may become particularly relevant when the agent decides not to continue the relationship.

THE DIFFERENCE LIES IN HOW YHE RELATIONSHIP ENDS

Article 30 of the LCA excludes entitlement to goodwill indemnity in three circumstances: where the principal terminates the agreement because the agent has failed to fulfil their legal or contractual obligations; where the agent terminates the agreement by notice, subject to the exceptions provided for by law; and where, with the principal's consent, the agent assigns their contractual rights and obligations to a third party.

In particular, termination by the agent does not result in the loss of entitlement where it is justified by circumstances attributable to the principal or is based on the agent's age, disability or illness, making it unreasonable to require the agent to continue their activities. The statutory exception is therefore not limited to a prior breach by the principal.

Outside these exceptions, an agent bound by an agreement of indefinite duration who decides to terminate the relationship loses the right to goodwill indemnity. But does the same apply where the agreement has a fixed term and the agent decides not to enter into another agreement when the previous one expires?

REFUSING TO SIGN A NEW AGREEMENT IS NOT THE SAME AS TERMINATING THE PREVIOUS ONE

A decision not to enter into a new agreement for a further period is not, in itself, equivalent to the termination by notice referred to in Article 30(b) of the LCA. Where the relationship ends upon completion of the agreed term, the reason for termination is the expiry of the agreement.

In such circumstances, the agent may retain the right to goodwill indemnity even if they reject an offer from the principal to enter into a new agreement, provided that the requirements of Article 28 are met and no other statutory ground for exclusion applies.¹

Refusing to enter into a new agreement upon expiry of the previous one does not, in itself, amount to terminating the agency relationship by notice.

WHAT IF SUCCESSIVE AGREEMENTS HAVE BENN SIGNED OVER SEVERAL YEARS?

A succession of fixed-term agreements does not necessarily mean that they must all be regarded as a single agreement of indefinite duration. The case law cited has taken into account the parties' intention to enter into separate agreements for defined periods.²

However, this situation must be distinguished from that provided for in Article 24(2) of the LCA: if both parties continue to perform the agreement after the originally agreed term has expired, the agreement is deemed to have been converted into one of indefinite duration.

Consequently, it is not sufficient merely to verify that the signed documents contain an expiry date. It is necessary to examine how the successive agreements were formalised and how the relationship actually developed following each expiry.

Before giving notice of the end of the relationship or rejecting a new agreement, it is advisable to analyse the actual duration of the contractual relationship, the renewal conditions and the grounds for termination. These factors may be decisive in determining whether the agent retains the right to goodwill indemnity.

LEGISLATIVE AND CASE LAW REFERENCES

Legislation. Law 12/1992 of 27 May on Agency Agreements, Articles 24, 28 and 30. Council Directive 86/653/EEC of 18 December 1986.

1. Expiry and conclusion of a new agreement. Spanish Supreme Court, Civil Chamber, Judgment 716/2006 of 4 July (Appeal No. 4874/1999); Murcia Provincial Court, Section 1, Judgment 485/2025; Madrid Provincial Court, Section 19, Judgment 31/2025 of 22 January (Appeal No. 453/2023); Vizcaya Provincial Court, Section 4, Judgment 794/1999 of 27 July; Navarra Provincial Court, Section 1, Judgment 194/2004 of 12 November (Appeal No. 300/2003).

2. Successive fixed-term agreements. Spanish Supreme Court, Civil Chamber, Judgment 1077/2004 of 4 November (Appeal No. 3055/1998), Fourth Ground of Law; Girona Provincial Court, Judgment 360/2004 of 5 November; Ávila Provincial Court, Judgment 174/2010 of 2 July; Valladolid Provincial Court, Judgment 27/2016 of 1 February; Barcelona Provincial Court, Section 17, Judgment 186/2020 of 17 September (Appeal No. 833/2019).

Contact request

* Required fields

Personal data protection.

Data controller: ,
,

The purpose of the processing of your data is to respond to your queries and/or requests for information, based on your consent given when you provide your data (article 6.1.a, GDPR).
You may exercise the following rights over your data,

  • The right of information, access, rectification, objection, erasure ("to be forgotten"), restriction of
    processing, portability, non-transferability, to the limitation of processing, portability, not to be subject to automated individual decisions.
  • Remember that exercising your rights is free of charge. You can also lodge a complaint with the
    supervisory authority.

You can access the legal notice and the complete information here


Drag the arrow into the white box to activate the button

 

 

 

COSCULLUELA

COSCULLUELA E IBARRA ABOGADOS

You can complete our contact form

Contact